Speaker should choose LoP even if no clear applicable rule: Somnath Chatterjee
NEW DELHI: Former Lok Sabha speaker Somnath Chatterjee
said the current speaker of the lower house Sumitra Mahajan should designate a
member of the Lower House of Parliament as Leader of the Opposition even if “there
is no clear applicable rule.”
“That will also put an end to the fact that Indian
Parliament does not have a LoP, which will weaken democratic system we have
adopted,” the former Speaker, who presided over the 14th Lok Sabha from
At the outset, he made it clear that 10 per cent of
the membership of the Lok Sabha is needed for an Opposition party to be given
the status of the Leader of the Opposition. He, however, hastened to add that
the issue should be left to the discretion of the Speaker.
“So far as I know 10 per cent of the membership of the
House, I think this should be left to the discretion of the Speaker,” he said
when asked as to what was the criteria for a member of a party to get the LoP
status and what should be done in the current situation.
“I believe for the proper functioning, someone should
be designated as LoP, which recognises the important role of the opposition in
an elected democratic setup. Therefore, I feel even if there is no clear
applicable rule, Honourable Speaker may kindly in her discretion designate an
honourable member of the House to be the LoP. Who will be designated should be
decided by the number of members of different parties have in the House,” he
Chatterjee’s remarks came in the backdrop of Attorney
General Mukul Rohatgi opining that Congress is not eligible and there is no
precedent since the days of the first Lok Sabha to grant the post to a party
which does not have the minimum required MPs.
The AG’s opinion came as a setback to Congress which
has made a strong pitch for the Leader of Opposition post despite securing just
44 seats in the 543-member House. A party has to win 55 seats to get 10 per
Sources said that Rohatgi had conveyed his views to
Mahajan who had sought his opinion in view of the dilemma she is facing over
The top law officer of the country has said there is
no precedence where a party was given the LoP position -- the status of a
Cabinet Minister -- without meeting the criteria of 10 per cent seats since the
days of first Lok Sabha when GV Mavlankar was the Speaker.
Even during the time of Rajiv Gandhi in 1984, Congress
with over 400 seats had refused to grant LoP status to TDP for the same reason,
the AG has told the Speaker. The AG is also learnt to have rejected the
contention that LoP status could be given to the leader of Congress-led UPA
coalition as there is no such precedence. UPA has 60 members in the House.
BJP has said Congress may have to be content without
the LoP post in the Lok Sabha as it will be difficult for the Speaker to give
it to the party after she sought an opinion from the AG on the issue.